ILF Neurofeedback: Understanding Tourette Syndrome Through Nervous System Dysregulation and Cerebral Instability
written by Kasia McCartney
The neuropsychological rationale for Infra-Low Frequency Neurofeedback and its implications for long-term regulation
Tourette syndrome and other tic disorders have traditionally been approached through the lens of motor control, behavioural inhibition and neurotransmitter dysfunction. While these perspectives have contributed significantly to our understanding of the condition, an increasingly important
consideration is the role of broader neurological regulation: how the brain manages arousal, excitability, inhibition and the coordination of distributed neural networks.
A particularly interesting contribution to this developing perspective comes from Solberg and Solberg (2022), in their paper, Infra-low frequency neurofeedback in application to Tourette syndrome and other tic disorders: A clinical case series, published in Frontiers in Human Neuroscience. The authors explore the application of Infra-Low Frequency (ILF) neurofeedback in children and adolescents with Tourette syndrome and other tic disorders, presenting clinical outcomes from 100 consecutive cases. Their work offers an important opportunity to reconsider the underlying neuropsychological mechanisms associated with tics and, more importantly, the possibility of addressing the regulatory processes that contribute to their expression. Rather than focusing exclusively on suppressing the tic itself, the approach considers whether improving the brain's capacity for self-regulation may influence the wider pattern of neurological and behavioural difficulties experienced by these individuals.
Understanding Tourette syndrome beyond the motor symptom
Tourette syndrome is a neurodevelopmental condition characterised by motor and vocal tics, typically beginning during childhood. However, the clinical presentation is rarely limited to involuntary movements or vocalisations. Many individuals experience a considerably broader constellation of difficulties, including
heightened arousal, anxiety, attentional difficulties, obsessive-compulsive symptoms, emotional dysregulation, sensory sensitivities and sleep disturbances.
From a neuropsychological perspective, this raises an important question: are these difficulties simply separate conditions occurring alongside Tourette syndrome, or might some share underlying regulatory vulnerabilities? Contemporary neuroscience increasingly recognises that complex neurological and
neurodevelopmental presentations cannot always be understood by examining individual symptoms or isolated brain regions. Instead, they require consideration of the functional relationships between distributed neural systems. Motor output, emotional processing, attention, sensory integration and inhibitory control are not independent processes. They depend on the coordinated activity of interconnected cortical and subcortical structures. This is particularly relevant when considering the cortico-striato-thalamo-cortical (CSTC) circuits, which play an important role in motor control, action selection, habit formation and inhibitory
processes. Alterations in the functioning of these circuits have been implicated in Tourette syndrome.
However, the neuropsychological picture extends beyond motor circuitry. A person's capacity to regulate arousal, respond to environmental demands, process sensory information and maintain behavioural flexibility may also influence the frequency, intensity and functional impact of their tics.
It is within this broader understanding that ILF neurofeedback becomes particularly interesting.
The two major models: Dysregulation and cerebral instabilities
One of the most significant aspects of the Solberg and Solberg paper is its discussion of two complementary models used to understand tic expression within the ILF neurofeedback framework. These are the Dysregulation Model and the Cerebral Instability Model. Although they approach the problem from slightly different perspectives, both suggest that tics may be understood in relation to difficulties in the regulation and stability of neural activity.
1. The Dysregulation Model: Tics as an expression of impaired self-regulation
Within the Dysregulation Model, tics are conceptualised as an indication of an underlying regulatory deficit. The authors suggest that tic expression is strongly state-dependent. In clinical practice, tics may fluctuate considerably depending on an individual's emotional state, environmental demands, stress levels, fatigue and general arousal. This observation is important because it suggests that tic expression is not necessarily fixed. Rather, it can vary according to the individual's current regulatory state. The authors use the analogy of a car to explain the relationship between baseline arousal, excitability and inhibition. Baseline arousal can be compared to the engine idling, excitability to the responsiveness of the accelerator, and inhibition to the effectiveness of the brakes. When these processes are insufficiently regulated, the nervous system may become increasingly reactive. The individual may experience difficulty modulating their responses to internal and external stimulation.
In the context of Tourette syndrome, this may manifest as increased tic expression, heightened emotional reactivity, restlessness, anxiety or difficulty maintaining behavioural control. The authors describe some of the children they work with as having an excess of neurological energy, using the analogy of bubbles building up inside a champagne bottle. The effort required to contain this pressure can become increasingly difficult, and the resulting expression is not necessarily voluntary or intentional. This is an important clinical distinction. Tics should not be interpreted simply as behavioural choices or failures of conscious inhibition.
They may reflect difficulties in the neurological processes responsible for regulating excitability and coordinating responses.
From an ILF neurofeedback perspective, the therapeutic objective is therefore not simply to teach an individual to suppress their tics. It is to support the underlying regulatory capacity of the nervous system. The authors describe using individually selected cortical placements to influence these regulatory processes, with particular attention to calming excessive arousal and improving the individual's capacity for self-regulation. This represents a meaningful shift in therapeutic thinking: rather than concentrating exclusively on the visible symptom, treatment considers the neurological conditions that may contribute to its expression.
2. The Cerebral Instability Model: Understanding the episodic nature of tics
The second model discussed by Solberg and Solberg is the Cerebral Instability Model. This model considers the episodic nature of tics and their relationship with fluctuations in neuronal excitability. Tics do not occur at a constant rate. Their frequency and intensity can change throughout the day, sometimes substantially. Individuals may experience periods of relative stability followed by periods of increased tic activity. The authors propose that these fluctuations may be understood in the context of cerebral instability. From this perspective, difficulties in maintaining stable neural activity and coordinating interactions between different regions of the brain may contribute to the intermittent expression of symptoms.
This is where the concept of interhemispheric connectivity becomes particularly relevant. The authors identify bilateral training, particularly through homotopic placements, as an important component of their approach. Their primary starting placement for addressing cerebral instabilities is interhemispheric training between corresponding temporal regions. The rationale is to support improved coordination between the cerebral hemispheres, with the broader objective of promoting cerebral stability and reducing excessive neuronal excitability. The paper also draws attention to epilepsy as an example of a condition involving cerebral
instability. The authors describe working with individuals who experience both tic disorders and epilepsy, highlighting the importance of interhemispheric stabilisation within their clinical approach. Importantly, these models are clinical frameworks underpinning the authors' ILF protocol approach. They should not be interpreted as established explanations of the complete neurobiology of Tourette syndrome.
Nevertheless, they provide an interesting framework through which to consider why symptoms may fluctuate and why interventions targeting broader regulatory processes could have effects extending beyond tic frequency alone.
Why ILF neurofeedback is particularly relevant
Infra-Low Frequency neurofeedback operates within an exceptionally slow frequency range, engaging the brain's endogenous regulatory processes through feedback derived from ongoing electrical activity. Unlike conventional approaches that focus primarily on reinforcing specific frequency bands associated with particular cognitive or behavioural functions, ILF neurofeedback is concerned with supporting the brain's capacity for self-regulation. The approach is based on the premise that the brain can respond to feedback concerning its own ongoing activity, with training parameters individually optimised according to the person's
response.
In the Solberg and Solberg clinical approach, two-channel ILF neurofeedback is used to provide differential feedback from selected cortical locations. The authors describe selecting and adjusting these locations according to individual symptom profiles, clinical observations and ongoing feedback. This individualisation is particularly important when working with Tourette syndrome because the condition can present with considerable variation in symptom expression and associated difficulties. For one individual, heightened arousal and anxiety may be the most significant difficulties. For another, attention, emotional reactivity, obsessive thoughts or sensory processing may be more prominent.
Consequently, the objective is not to apply an identical protocol to every individual with a tic disorder, but to identify the regulatory difficulties that appear most relevant to their presentation. An important consideration is that improvement in self-regulation may have implications for several functional domains simultaneously. If an individual becomes less physiologically reactive, for example, this may influence their ability to tolerate sensory stimulation, manage frustration, maintain attention and participate in everyday activities. This broader functional perspective is one of the most interesting aspects of ILF neurofeedback in
neurodevelopmental presentations.
The clinical findings: What did the researchers actually observe?
The paper presents outcomes from 100 consecutive children and adolescents aged between 8 and 18 years, with an average age of 12. The participants had received neurofeedback as their primary treatment, generally completing between 30 and 40 sessions. Many had previously experienced insufficient benefit from conventional treatment approaches or had been referred because of difficulties with standard interventions.
The researchers used several methods to evaluate progress, including individualised Goal Attainment Scaling (GAS) and systematic symptom tracking. Rather than evaluating treatment exclusively through tic frequency, the authors assessed changes across a much broader range of functional difficulties.
The findings were particularly encouraging:
The principal outcomes included:
- More than 90% of participants met or exceeded their expected treatment goals according to Goal Attainment Scaling.
- 45% average reduction in the severity of the ten most significant reported problem areas.
- 45% median symptom improvement, with 90% of participants experiencing an improvement of at least 35% in their tracked symptoms.
- Improvements were observed across both male and female participants, without a significant difference in overall improvement between the sexes.
These findings are important because they suggest that the potential benefits of ILF neurofeedback may extend beyond the reduction of individual tics.
The researchers reported improvements in overall functioning, with many children and adolescents demonstrating a greater ability to engage with their environment, participate in daily activities and reach their developmental potential. It is worth noting that the 45% figure represents the reduction in the ten most severe tracked problem areas, rather than a specifically measured 45% reduction in tic frequency. This distinction is essential when interpreting the findings.
Nevertheless, the results suggest that a therapeutic approach directed towards broader regulatory processes may offer clinically meaningful benefits for individuals whose difficulties extend beyond tic expression.
The significance of co-morbidities: A broader neuropsychological picture
Perhaps one of the most clinically relevant aspects of the paper is its recognition that Tourette syndrome frequently occurs alongside other neurodevelopmental, psychological and functional difficulties. The authors discuss several associated presentations, including:
ADHD and attentional difficulties
Attentional difficulties are common in the clinical population described. Some children were receiving stimulant medication, including methylphenidate, for secondary attention problems. The authors discuss how medication dosage and individual sensitivity may influence arousal and emotional regulation, highlighting the importance of considering the wider regulatory profile when evaluating treatment.
Anxiety and heightened arousal
Anxiety and stress are frequently observed in the children and adolescents treated by the authors. These difficulties may interact with tic expression, creating a cycle in which heightened arousal contributes to increased symptoms, which may subsequently increase distress and anticipatory anxiety.
Addressing the individual's capacity to regulate arousal may therefore have implications beyond the tics themselves.
Obsessive-compulsive symptoms
The paper describes obsessive thoughts, repetitive behaviours, rituals and perfectionistic tendencies in this population. The authors discuss the relationship between anxiety, internal stressors and obsessive-compulsive patterns, describing the use of neurofeedback alongside cognitive behavioural therapy.
An interesting observation is that some individuals appeared less preoccupied with rituals and compulsive behaviours during treatment, potentially making them more able to participate in the exposure-based components of CBT.
Epilepsy
Epilepsy is another important co-occurring neurological condition discussed in the paper. The authors describe their clinical experience using interhemispheric training to support neurological stability in individuals presenting with both epilepsy and tic disorders. This is particularly interesting when considering the broader concept of cerebral instability and the possibility that different neurological presentations may share certain difficulties in the regulation of neural activity. However, epilepsy and Tourette syndrome remain distinct neurological conditions, and the proposed relationship should not be interpreted as evidence of a shared underlying mechanism in every individual.
Autistic traits and sensory processing
The authors also discuss children presenting with autistic traits, sensory difficulties and challenges with social functioning. This is clinically relevant because sensory processing, arousal regulation and the ability to adapt to environmental demands can significantly influence everyday functioning. For some individuals, what appears to be behavioural difficulty may be closely associated with the amount of sensory and physiological demand placed on their nervous system.
PTSD, early attachment difficulties and emotional regulation
The paper additionally discusses PTSD and the consequences of early attachment difficulties, recognising that emotional and physiological regulation can be influenced by developmental experiences. Taken together, these presentations highlight why a narrow focus on tic suppression may be insufficient for many individuals. Tourette syndrome does not exist in isolation from the rest of the person's neuropsychological functioning. A comprehensive therapeutic approach must consider the interaction between motor symptoms, emotional processing, attention, sensory integration, sleep and broader nervous system regulation.
Beyond symptom reduction: The importance of long-term self-regulation
One of the most interesting questions raised by the paper concerns the durability of treatment effects. If ILF neurofeedback supports improvements in the brain's regulatory capacity, could these improvements translate into more sustainable changes in everyday functioning?
The authors report that, based on their clinical experience since 2005, approximately one in ten former clients returns following a partial recurrence of symptoms or problematic behaviours. They identify several circumstances that may contribute to this recurrence, including adolescence, major life events, trauma and challenging environmental or family dynamics. In these cases, the authors typically recommend between five and ten booster sessions. They also report that many individuals retain sufficient self-regulation, robustness and resilience to function more effectively in their everyday environments following treatment. This is a particularly important observation. The potential value of neurofeedback is not simply whether an individual experiences fewer tics during or immediately after a training session. It is whether improvements in regulatory capacity translate into greater independence, emotional stability, behavioural flexibility and resilience in
everyday life.
For a child with Tourette syndrome, this might mean being able to participate more comfortably in the classroom, tolerate frustration, manage transitions, engage socially and experience less interference from symptoms. It may also mean reducing the cumulative psychological burden associated with living with a
condition that can affect confidence, relationships, education and social participation. There is, however, an important scientific distinction to make. The authors explicitly acknowledge that they have not conducted formal long-term follow-up studies. Their observations are based on clinical experience and informal indicators rather than prospective longitudinal outcome data.
Consequently, the findings are encouraging, but they do not establish the long-term efficacy or permanence of treatment effects. Further controlled research with systematic follow-up would be valuable in determining how durable these improvements are and which individuals are most likely to benefit.
Rethinking the therapeutic objective: From controlling tics to improving neurological function
One of the most important clinical implications of this work is the opportunity to reconsider what successful treatment should look like. Historically, therapeutic success in Tourette syndrome has often been evaluated through the frequency and severity of motor and vocal tics. While these remain important clinical outcomes, they do not necessarily capture the full impact of the condition or the individual's ability to function. An individual may experience a reduction in tics but continue to struggle with anxiety, sensory hypersensitivity, sleep disturbances, attentional difficulties or emotional dysregulation.
Equally, improvements in these broader functional domains may represent meaningful clinical progress even when some tic activity remains. This distinction is important when considering ILF neurofeedback. The underlying therapeutic objective is to support the nervous system's ability to regulate itself, rather than simply encouraging the suppression of a particular behaviour. From this perspective, tic reduction may be one expression of improved neurological regulation,
rather than the sole indicator of therapeutic success. It also reinforces the importance of individualised treatment, careful symptom monitoring and ongoing evaluation of functional outcomes.
The long-term implications for neurofeedback and Tourette syndrome
The Solberg and Solberg paper contributes to an important developing conversation within clinical neuroscience: the possibility of addressing neurological dysregulation through interventions that target functional regulation rather than isolated symptoms. Its findings are particularly relevant for individuals who have not experienced sufficient benefit from conventional treatment, those who experience difficulties with medication, and those whose presentations involve multiple co-occurring challenges.
The reported outcomes suggest that ILF neurofeedback may offer a valuable complementary therapeutic approach, with potential benefits extending across several areas of functioning. However, the field requires further investigation. Larger controlled studies, comparison groups, standardised tic-specific outcome measures and formal long-term follow-up are needed to establish efficacy, identify mechanisms and determine the durability of treatment effects.
There is also an opportunity for future research to investigate whether improvements in clinical functioning correspond with measurable changes in neural connectivity, excitability or other neurophysiological markers. Such work could help clarify the relationship between the dysregulation and cerebral instability
models and the broader neuroscience of Tourette syndrome.
Ultimately, what makes this paper particularly interesting is its emphasis on the individual as more than the sum of their symptoms. A child presenting with Tourette syndrome is not simply experiencing a motor disorder. They are navigating a developing nervous system that must continuously coordinate movement, attention, emotional responses, sensory information and interactions with the environment. When these regulatory processes become compromised, the consequences may extend into multiple areas of development and everyday life.
An approach that considers the wider regulatory functioning of the nervous system therefore has considerable clinical relevance. The longer-term ambition of ILF neurofeedback is not simply to reduce the expression of tics, but to support a nervous system that is better able to regulate, adapt and respond to the
demands of everyday life. For individuals with Tourette syndrome and other tic disorders, this represents a promising direction for complementary, individualised and functionally oriented treatment.
Reference: Solberg, B., & Solberg, E. (2022). Infra-low frequency neurofeedback in application to Tourette syndrome and other tic disorders: A clinical case series. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 16, 891924. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnhum.2022.891924